Alan Turing
Posted in Media, Politics on September 11th, 2009 by Les – 2 CommentsAlan Turing withoubt any doubt was a hero. Like many during a time of war he applied his unique talents to the benefit of the nation then and now. There can be no doubt that The Few that Churchill spoke of could count Turing and his bletchley park cohorts among their number.
There can be no more doubt that the way he was treated after the war for his homosexuality was despicable; no right minded person could think otherwise. But the laws of the time were exactly that. They were of their time. They were the laws of a society that hadn’t itself grown up. In the fifties particularly, Science itself still considered homosexuality a mental affliction. The Hobson’s choice of prison or chemical castration from which Turing was forced to choose after conviction are abhorrent to most of us now and rightly so.
And so it was that when I came across a petition on the number 10 website to have the Prime Minister apologise for Turing’s treatment at the hands of the state that I very nearly added my support. But then I stopped. Why should today’s goverment apologise for unjust laws two generations ago? It’s not the first time and I’m sure it won’t be the last but come on, really? What’s the point? It’s not like the pm is contemporary with the legislation or the events. We’re not talking missing weapons of mass destruction and illegal wars in the lifetime of the current government!
I just don’t understand what it is about society today that a portion must lobby the goverment of the day to apologise for the wrongs of previous incumbents. After all, goverments are a little like companies. There are 60 million shareholders and every few years we get to elect a whole new board of directors. We give them powers to make decisions and laws and we, the society of the moment abide by those laws for the most part because our democracy ensures that the law works for most people most of the time.
If you really want an apology for fifty year old injustices I suggest you lobby not today’s government but your own grandparents, and their peers who were the very society who, collectively and very likely out of apathy rather than malice allowed bad laws to last even beyond their generation. To be fair, the focus of the multitide in post-war Britain was unlikely to be laws relating to homosexuality so even “apathy” may be a bit strong. But whatever the justification, it certainly is not something that today’s politicians should be expected to apologise for.
The government today can only be accountable for things enacted in its name during its lifetime. Stop looking for someone to blame and recognise the past when you see it.